There are many songs that leave the listeners with a melancholy but for me “I Can't Tell You Why” is # 1.
This was the first song The Eagles completed for The Long Run. They finished the song in March 1978, but the album took about 19 months to complete and wasn't released until September 1979. It was The Eagles last studio album until they re-formed in 1994.
Glenn Frey played lead guitar on this song, which was rare at the time since Don Felder or Joe Walsh usually played lead, relegating Frey to rhythm.
In an interview,
Frey said that this and "One Of These Nights" were the two Eagles
songs he would put into a time capsule to represent The Eagles best work. [www.songfacts.com]
Even though I like the covers below, for some reasons the original is always on my mind and in my heart, but ... I can't tell you why!!
Howard Hewett [1990]
Vince Gill [1993]
The Cruel Sea [2002]
Diana Krall [2015]
Edsilia Rombley [2018]